WHY THAT BRAND VOICE WORKBOOK DIDN’T WORK (DESPITE YOUR BEST EFFORTS, YOU OVERACHIEVER, YOU)

May 18, 2026

General

Trying to find your brand voice solo is like trying to read the label from inside the bottle. Let’s talk about what those five adjectives can’t tell you.

There’s a very particular kind of optimism that comes with downloading a brand voice workbook.

“Find Your Brand Voice in Five Easy Steps.”

“The Ultimate Guide to Brand Voice Clarity.”

“How to Sound Like Yourself and Make 2 Million Dollars Doing It.”

Okay, I made that last one up.

You make yourself a coffee. 

Clear your schedule. 

Close approximately all tabs so you can really focus on yourself.

You follow the instructions.

You journal your little heart out. 

You answer questions about your values, your personality, your mission, your ideal clients, your hopes, your dreams, your deepest childhood traumas…Okay, probably not that last one.

You highlight your favourite sentences like the A+ little overachiever you are. 

You pick your five adjectives. 

You write a rather lovely paragraph about what your brand stands for. Maybe you even get a little emotional.

This is it. The clarity you’ve been looking for.

The PDF is complete.

The dopamine is dopamining.

Your brand voice has been FOUND.

…until you sit down to write an email.

You open your shiny new brand voice document.

You read it.

You read it again.

“Bold. Conversational. Playful. Approachable. Authentic.”

Excellent.

What the fuck am I supposed to do with that?

You’re right back where you started, staring at the blinking cursor, wondering why writing for your own business still feels like an elaborate psychological experiment.

Congratulations on completing your workbook, though.

via GIPHY

I’m sure it’ll enjoy spending the rest of its natural life in your Google Drive, somewhere between the abandoned Notion templates and that course you swore you’d finish in 2022.

A confession from the brand voice department

Before I get too comfortable roasting the humble brand voice workbook, I should probably disclose that I’ve used these exercises with clients.

I’ve created versions of them, too.

I meant well. I swear. Don’t come for me.

When I started working in brand voice, the whole process of helping someone describe their personality through a series of questions made sense to me.

You ask someone how they want to sound, you ask them to choose adjectives, you explore their values, the feelings they want to create, what makes them different.

And I still think there’s value in some of those questions.

BUUUUTTTT (big but) after spending years getting increasingly obsessed with brand voice, personality, and all the weird little intricacies of how humans communicate, I realized the answers people gave me on paper rarely told me nearly as much as the people themselves did.

Someone could hand me a beautifully completed questionnaire full of thoughtful answers, and I’d have a decent understanding of how they wanted their brand to be perceived, or more specifically, how they felt they should want their brand to be perceived.

Then we’d get on a call.

They’d start talking about their work, telling me a story, going off on some completely unexpected tangent.

They’d use an expression I’d never heard before, make a joke, explain something through a bizarre analogy, get a little fired up about something that annoyed them.

And I’d be sitting there thinking…

Wait wait wait.

Go back.

THAT.

What you just said. The way you said it.

Can we talk about THAT?

Those moments told me things that five carefully selected adjectives never could.

Not because the person hadn’t tried hard enough to describe their voice in the workbook.

They simply hadn’t thought to mention them.

Your brain is a terrible witness to its own crimes

There’s a funny little thing that happens when someone asks you to describe your own voice.

Five minutes ago, you were a perfectly functioning human with opinions, jokes, peculiar expressions, a whole-ass personality and everything.

Now you’re staring at a workbook prompt asking you to describe your communication style, and suddenly it feels like a job interview.

Sarcastic? Hmm. Sounds a little unprofessional.

Opinionated? Ehhhh. Don’t want anyone thinking I’m difficult.

Playful? Ooooh, that’s nice. Let’s go with playful.

Fabulous. We’ve taken a fully functioning personality and given it the LinkedIn treatment.

Nobody panic. We’re very approachable now.

The problem for the most of us is, the second you’re asked to describe yourself, you start filtering your answers through approximately 900 things that have fuck all to do with how you actually communicate.

You’re thinking about the clients you want to attract (and impress), the brands you’ve been admiring (and possibly low-key comparing yourself to), the way someone in your industry should sound, and whether admitting you have the sense of humour of a 14-year-old boy is going to hurt your credibility.

So you start making little adjustments.

A bit less sarcasm, a smidge more professionalism, and a dash of “authentic” for good measure.

There she is. The woman. The myth. The employable legend.

Before you know it, you’ve written a perfectly respectable description of someone who sounds like they’d be a pleasure to work with. Whether that person bears any resemblance to you is…up for debate.

Now, imagine answering those same questions over drinks with a friend.

There’s an unnecessary tangent, a wildly specific analogy, a joke that probably needs some context (and possibly an apology), and you’ve somehow managed to explain your entire business philosophy through a scene from a movie you watched in 2007.

Ohhhhh, hello. Who’s this?

THAT’S the stuff I’m interested in.

The way you tell the story, the words you reach for without thinking, the weird connections your brain makes, the things you say when you’re too busy enjoying the conversation to worry about whether you sound sufficiently “on brand.”

I’m not saying we need to drag every questionable joke and unfiltered opinion into your business. Some of those can stay safely in the group chat, thank you very much. But I’d sure as hell like to know they exist before we decide what belongs in your brand voice.

The workbook got the job-interview version of you.

I’d like to meet the one who didn’t rehearse her answers.

You’re trying to read the label from inside the bottle

There’s an analogy I love for this.

Trying to recognize your own voice can feel a lot like trying to read the label from inside the bottle.

You’ve got all the information. You’re literally surrounded by it.

Unfortunately, your face is pressed up against the glass, and everything looks like absolute nonsense.

You know your own jokes, your favourite expressions, your little verbal habits. The strange connections your brain makes between things.

You’ve been living with them for years.

So, naturally, they don’t strike you as particularly interesting.

That’s just how it is.

It’s a bit like how you stop noticing the weird smell in your own house until someone comes over. Hypothetically, of course.

Meanwhile, ask that same person to describe one of their favourite clients.

Oh, NOW we’re talking.

They’ll tell you exactly what makes that person brilliant. How they explain complicated things. The peculiar little expressions they use. 

Their sense of humour. The way they make people feel. The stuff that makes working with them so enjoyable.

You might even get a few rather entertaining impressions.

They can see all those details because they have some distance from them.

Then you ask what makes their own communication distinctive.

“Um…I’m pretty friendly?”

Sweet Jesus.

We’re back to the adjectives.

via GIPHY

And this is where the workbook format really starts to show its limitations.

It’s asking you to recognize and articulate nuances that you’re often 

too close to notice.

Nuances you may not even realize are worth paying attention to.

The stuff that doesn’t make it into the workbook

I’ve come to believe that a lot of the most interesting clues about someone’s voice show up in conversation.

Particularly the bits nobody planned.

The story they suddenly remember halfway through answering a question.

The specific words they reach for when they’re explaining something they REALLY care about.

The little change in their energy when the conversation shifts to something they find fascinating.

This wonderfully theatrical way they have of describing the most mundane things.

None of those details necessarily make it onto a worksheet.

For example:

You could have a perfectly reasonable prompt asking someone to describe their sense of humour.

They might write “sarcastic.”

Cool.

We’ve narrowed it down to approximately half the internet.

But get them talking, and suddenly you can hear how their sarcasm works.

Are they deadpan? Playfully dramatic? Fond of an overly elaborate insult? Constantly making references that require an encyclopedic knowledge of early-2000s television?

Do they use humour to make people comfortable? To challenge ideas? To point out the absurdity of something?

THAT’S the nuance I’m interested in.

That’s the stuff we can start making intentional decisions about.

And it’s often much easier to notice when somebody else is listening.

Someone who can interrupt your perfectly sensible explanation to say, “Sorry, what the hell was that expression you just used?”

Someone who notices the joke you nearly skipped over.

Someone who can hear something interesting in the way you explain your work, even when you think you’re just rambling.

I love being that person for my clients, but it doesn’t have to be a professional brand voice nerd with a suspicious number of browser tabs open.

A friend can do it. An internet colleague or collaborator. Someone who knows you well enough to recognize your peculiarities but still has enough perspective to point them out.

Hell, you can learn a surprising amount from listening back to yourself in a conversation.

The important bit is getting out of your own head long enough to notice what’s happening when you’re not concentrating so hard on getting your voice “right”.

So, should we ceremonially burn all the workbooks?

Tempting. I do love a good bonfire, but no.

I’m not suggesting every brand voice exercise is entirely without merit.

A good question can get you thinking about something you’ve never considered before.

It can help you recognize what you want to express more of, what you’ve been holding back, or how you’d like your brand to feel.

That’s useful.

I just don’t think completing a workbook automatically gives you a clear understanding (or usable understanding) of your brand voice.

It’s a starting point. At best.

The real fun tends to happen when we take those initial answers and start poking at them.

You said you want your voice to be playful. Okay, show me what playful looks like to you.

Tell me about someone whose humour you love.

Show me something you’ve written that made you laugh.

Let’s listen to what comes out.

Then let’s talk about which parts you’d like to bring into your brand, what you’d rather leave out, and what else you might want to experiment with.

That’s where we start getting somewhere interesting.

And unlike that beautifully completed PDF, we can actually use what we find.

TL;DR: Your homework involves another human. Sorry.

Put down the workbook. We’re trying something else.

1. Recruit a willing participant.

A friend, collaborator, business bestie, whoever. Preferably someone you can talk to without feeling the need to put on your professional-business-owner pants.

Who knew? Human interaction. Horrifyingly useful.

2. Have an actual conversation. I’ve even got some prompts for you.

Find somewhere comfy, pour yourselves a little something, and pick a few questions to riff on.

  • What’s something people in your industry do or say that drives you absolutely BONKERS?
  • Tell me about a recent moment in your business when you thought, “Holy shit, THIS is why I love what I do.”
  • What’s something you believe about your work that other people might disagree with?
  • What’s a story from your business that you LOVE telling people?
  • What’s something about your work you could talk about for 45 minutes without realizing 45 minutes had passed?

Please don’t sit there taking turns reading questions off your phone like you’re on the world’s least romantic first date.

Follow the tangents, the follow-up questions, etc. And, for the love of God, don’t rehearse your answers.

3. Give them permission to interrupt you.

Ask them to flag anything that sounds particularly you. The weird expressions, the way you explain something, the joke they loved, the moment you went on a 12-minute tirade about something seemingly insignificant.

Bonus points if you record the conversation (with permission, obviously) and listen back.

4. Steal their notes.

Pay attention to what they noticed, especially the things you wouldn’t have thought twice about.

Try bringing one or two of those little discoveries into your next email, caption, or whatever WordThing™ you’ve got on the docket.

No need to declare your brand voice officially FOUND, we’re just collecting evidence.

Your workbook asked you to describe how you communicate.

This little exercise lets you catch yourself actually doing it.

Funny what happens when we stop trying so damn hard to give the right answer.


WANT A PROFESSIONAL SET OF EARS ON THE CASE?

Conveniently, I own two. They’re attached to a brand voice nerd who finds your weird little communication habits disproportionately fascinating. Voice on the Rocks is where we put them to work, excavating the nuances you can’t see from inside the bottle and figuring out what the hell to do with them.

Come talk my ears off.

PREFER AN AUDIO EXPERIENCE? THERE’S A PODCAST EPISODE FOR THAT.

Come listen to me roast brand voice workbooks + explain why another pair of ears is worth more than another 12 pages of existential self-reflection.

Give your eyeballs a break and listen on Spotify

THIRSTY FOR MORE WORDTHINGS?

There’s an open stool at The Write Pour with your name on it. A weekly-ish dispatch tucked into a dimly lit, jukebox-fuelled corner of the internet where the stories are the point and the newsletters read like letters.

Writing gets weirdly lonely. But, in my experience, it gets a little easier when someone slides a story across the bar and says, “same.”

Pour me some “same.”

May 19, 2026

People spend on average about 43.56% of their time writing or thinking about writing for their business.

Okay, I made that up. But I had you going for a second, didn’t I?

read More

May 19, 2026

So this is the one where we talk shit about frameworks, formulas, and best practices.

They’re inherently bad. But I’ve also got beef with what these things turn into when we stop questioning them.

read More

May 19, 2026

Today, we’re gonna talk about messaging. Because you really cant talk about voice without talking about messaging at least a little bit. And, just like voice can feel like this concept, messaging can feel hella confusing when you’re trying to figure it out for yourself. If you’ve ever tried to get your messaging together, you […]

read More

You might also be into…

THE WRITE POUR

Join…

Weekly-ish installments on the side-quests, writing spirals, napkin thoughts, and tiny “wait, that’s exactly it” moments that don’t always fit neatly on a homepage, but do make you feel less alone writing for your business.

© 2026 Steph Laffy Copy & Brand | Site Credit | Privacy Policy | Cookies Lore | Terms of Service

Boring legal stuff 👉🏼